Bagel Basket Cafe Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Bagel Basket Cafe, a delightful haven for breakfast and brunch enthusiasts. Located at 639 Commack Rd, Commack, NY, this inviting spot serves up an impressive array of bagels, egg sandwiches, and gourmet breakfast wraps, ensuring there's something for everyone.
The menu boasts a variety of bagels—from classic sesame to unique blueberry, including gluten-free options, perfect for those seeking a lighter treat. Try the French Toast Bagel or indulge in their mini bagels for a bite-sized flavor explosion.
For breakfast lovers, options like the Hungryman sandwich, loaded with bacon, sausage, and eggs, promise to satisfy your cravings. Pair your meal with a fresh cup of coffee for a true morning delight. With a cozy, family-oriented environment and efficient service, Bagel Basket Cafe swiftly whips up delectable dishes that keep customers coming back for more.
Whether you're dining in or taking out, this cafe is not just a meal; it’s an experience worth savoring.
Bagels
Bagel
Various bagels available in flavors like sesame, garlic, and blueberry, including gluten-free and whole wheat options.
French Toast Bagel
This toasted with butter.
Flagel
Flat bagel.
Mini Bagel
Enjoy a bite-sized delight, prepared with your choice of a plain, poppy seed, sesame, or everything mini bagel. A perfect smaller companion to your main meal.
Bialy
Contains minced onions.
Dozen Bagels
Buy a dozen, get 2 more bagels for free! Please let us know per instructions (i.e. plain - 14) flagels, bialy, french toast bagels, gluten-free are not included.
Kaiser Roll
Seedless rolls available.
Meat, 2 Eggs, Cheese
Hungryman
Bacon, sausage, ham, 3 eggs & cheese on a hero.
Meat, 2 Eggs
On your choice of bread and more.
2 Eggs, Cheese
On your choice of bread and more.
Pancakes
Buttermilk pancakes served with syrup and butter (optional).
Western Omelette
Includes ham, onion, peppers.
French Toast
Served with syrup and butter,
Home Fries
Served in 12 oz. or 16 oz. containers. contains bacon bits.
Greek Omelette
Includes spinach, tomato, onion, feta cheese.
2 Eggs
On your choice of bread & more.
Cheese Omelette
Includes four slices of cheese.
B.B.C. Pancakes
Buttermilk pancakes with strawberries and walnuts.
Lox Omelette
Delicious nova.
Vegetable Omelette
Includes spinach, tomato, onion, mushrooms, peppers.
Spanish Omelette
Includes peppers, onion, tomato, jalapeo.
Breakfast
Gourmet Breakfast Wraps
Classic Wrap
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage, with scrambled eggs, american cheese, in a plain wrap.
Western Breakfast Wrap
Ham, scrambled eggs, peppers, onions, in a plain wrap.
Healthy Breakfast Wrap
Turkey, 3 egg whites, tomato, alpine lace swiss, in a whole wheat wrap.
BBC Breakfast Wrap
Egg whites, spinach, alpine lace swiss, tomato, in a whole wheat wrap.
Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad
Chicken salad with cranberries and walnuts, served in your choice of wrap, toast or bagel, including options like spinach wrap, tomato wrap, croissant and various toast types.
Vegetable Tuna Sandwich
Vegetable tuna sandwich served with your choice of bread - options include white toast, whole wheat toast, rye toast, kaiser roll, seedless kaiser roll, and more.
Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich
Honey maple turkey served in your choice of breads or wraps.
Nova Sandwich
Savor a delectable sandwich boasting the unique, smoked taste of novalox. Complemented by your chosen bread, carrying an array of textures and flavors, this classic sandwich leaves you wanting more.
Lox Sandwich
Savor a delectable sandwich boasting the unique, smoked taste of novalox. Complemented by your chosen bread, carrying an array of textures and flavors, this classic sandwich leaves you wanting more.
Ovengold Turkey
Ovengold turkey served plain, with an option to choose from a variety of bread selections: lettuce wrap, white toast, spinach wrap, hero, whole wheat toast, rye toast, kaiser roll, or a croissant.
Roast Beef Sandwich
Roast beef sandwich with your choice of bread, including tomato wrap, whole wheat toast, lettuce wrap, and more.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Experience the delight of our tender tuna salad, nestled comfortably within your choice of bread. This simple yet satisfying ensemble is further enhanced with the crunch and freshness of lettuce. Choose to have it in a wrap, a croissant, toast or even a bagel to suit your preference.
BLT Sandwich
Blt with mayo on your choice of wrap, toast, roll, croissant, bagel, or flagel.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Enjoy our savoury chicken salad sandwich, layered between your choice of bread. Delight in the creamy texture and harmonic mix of seasonings with every bite. Choice of bread available.
Everroast Chicken Breast Sandwich
Savor the tantalizing essence of slow-cooked chicken breast that's tender to the taste, layered eloquently with your choice of bread or wrap. Comes paired with your usual sandwich companions for added flavor.
BLT Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken salad paired with the classic combination of bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Choose your bread from options including croissant, various wraps, toast, a hero, kaiser roll, or any bagel or flagel.
Cracked Pepper Turkey Sandwich
Cracked pepper turkey generously served with your choice of bread. Options include wraps, several types of toast, a croissant, a kaiser roll, or even a lettuce wrap.
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Breaded chicken cutlet served on your choice of bread, including wraps, toasts, or rolls.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken served on your choice of bread, including wraps, toasts, or rolls.
Pastrami Sandwich
Savor the rich, smoky flavor of tender pastrami nestled between your choice of bread - from a seedless kaiser roll to a crisp lettuce wrap. The sandwich is completed with the crunch of fresh lettuce and the creaminess of mayo. Enjoy the homestyle comfort in every bite.
Genoa Salami Sandwich
Enjoy a hearty genoa salami sandwich with your choice of bread such as hero, kaiser roll, tomato or spinach wrap, croissant, or even a lettuce wrap, among others.
Bologna Sandwich
Bologna sandwich served on your choice of bread, including a kaiser roll, plain wrap, tomato wrap, spinach wrap, whole wheat toast, seedless kaiser roll, croissant, rye toast, whole wheat wrap, white toast, hero, or lettuce wrap. For bagel or flagel, specify in the instructions.
Buffalo Chicken Breast Sandwich
Enjoy a hearty genoa salami sandwich with your choice of bread such as hero, kaiser roll, tomato or spinach wrap, croissant, or even a lettuce wrap, among others.
Salsalito Turkey Sandwich
Experience a delightful medley of flavors from the tender salsalito turkey, that is perfectly complemented with your choice of bread. Enjoy this classic sandwich as a light meal or hearty snack.
Buffalo Chicken Salad Sandwich
Experience a delightful medley of flavors from the tender salsalito turkey, that is perfectly complemented with your choice of bread. Enjoy this classic sandwich as a light meal or hearty snack.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Our egg salad sandwich features a classic, creamy egg salad. Choose from a variety of breads, including tomato wrap, rye toast, spinach wrap, croissant, white toast, seedless kaiser roll, hero, or a plain and whole wheat wrap or toast. Options for a unique flagel or bagel available upon instruction. Choose a lettuce wrap for a lighter touch.
Classic Sandwiches
Gourmet Wraps
W1. Vegetable Tuna Wrap
Vegetable tuna salad with roasted peppers and lettuce in a plain wrap.
W2. Southwestern Wrap
Grilled chicken, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato & chipotle mayo in a plain wrap.
W3. Steakhouse Wrap
Seasoned roast beef with caramelized onion, crumbled bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato and horseradish dressing in a plain wrap.
W4. Main Street Wrap
Grilled balsamic vegetables with fresh mozzarella, mixed baby greens and a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette in a plain wrap.
W5. North Shore Wrap
Cranberry walnut chicken salad with lettuce and tomato in a whole wheat wrap.
W6. Southbeach Wrap
Roast turkey with bacon, tomato, cucumber and mayo in an iceberg lettuce wrap.
W7. Smithtown Wrap
Honey chicken salad with crispy bacon, lettuce and tomato in a whole wheat wrap.
W8. Commack Slim Wrap
Mixed greens with feta cheese, olives, red onions, cucumber and balsamic vinaigrette in a plain wrap.
W9. Motor Parkway Wrap
Cracked pepper turkey with swiss cheese, mixed greens, tomato and honey mustard in a plain wrap.
W10. The Vanderbilt Wrap
Honey maple turkey with mixed greens, red onion, tomato, bleu cheese and balsamic vinaigrette in a plain wrap.
W11. The Hamlet Wrap
Turkey with mixed greens, tomato, red onion and sweet honey mustard in a plain wrap.
W12. Half Hollow Wrap
Ovengold turkey with swiss cheese, bacon, mixed greens, tomato and russian dressing in a whole wheat wrap.
W13. The Dix Hills Wrap
Grilled chicken, mixed greens & caesar dressing in a whole wheat wrap.
P1. The Commack Panini
Fresh mozzarella, sliced ripe tomato, roasted red peppers, fresh basil, drizzled with balsamic on rustic rosemary panini.
P2 . The Sawmill Panini
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, sundried tomato, pesto sauce on rustic rosemary panini.
P3. The Kicking Turkey Panini
Salsalito turkey, pepper jack cheese, tomato, chipotle mayo on european flat bread.
P4. The Veggie Panini
Thinly sliced balsamic-marinated grilled vegetables, fresh mozzarella on european whole wheat flat bread.
P5. The Indian Hollow Panini
Honey maple turkey, crispy bacon, melted cheddar, tomato and sweet honey mustard on european whole wheat flat bread.
P6. The Cougar Panini
Breaded chicken cutlet with melted mozzarella , bacon, tomato, and pesto mayo on a garlic parmesan panini.
P7. Rolling Hills Panini
Turkey with bacon, lettuce, tomato and pesto mayo on european flat bread.
P8. Wood Park Panini
Chicken cutlet with bacon, melted american cheese, lettuce, and russian dressing on european garlic panini.
P9. North Ridge Panini
Fried eggplant with fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and balsamic vinaigrette on garlic parmesan panini.
P10. The Burr Lane Panini
Seasoned roast beef with cheddar cheese, caramelized onions with horseradish sauce on a rustic onion panini.
Panini
Signature Sandwiches
The Banana Chicken Sandwich
Breaded chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, banana peppers, mayo and balsamic vinegar on a garlic hero.
The B.B.C. Sub
Cracked pepper turkey , crispy bacon, melted muenster cheese, cole slaw and russian dressing on a hero.
Roast Turkey Breast Sandwich
Roast turkey breast with crispy bacon, sundried tomato and pesto mayo on an onion roll.
The Commack High Sandwich
Honey maple turkey, melted mozzarella, crispy bacon, tomato and sweet honey mustard on a hero.
Honey Chicken Salad Sandwich
Honey chicken salad with crispy bacon, tomato and lettuce on whole wheat toast.
The Candlewood Sandwich
Breaded chicken cutlet with bacon, melted american, lettuce and russian dressing on a roll.
Death Wish Sandwich
Roast beef with melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and russian dressing on a garlic hero.
The Predator Sandwich
Breaded chicken cutlet with bacon, melted mozzarella and russian dressing on a garlic hero.
Italian Hero Sandwich
Capicola ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, onion and oil & vinegar on a hero.
The Cracked Turkey Sandwich
Cracked pepper turkey with melted provolone, lettuce, tomato and pesto mayo on a garlic hero.
The Bob -"O" Sandwich
Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic vinaigrette on a grilled garlic hero.
The Thunderbird Sandwich
Salsalito turkey with melted pepper jack cheese, tomato, banana peppers with mayo on a grilled hero.
Build Your Protein Bowl
Build your protein bowl with a choice of base roasted vegetables, quinoa & kale mix, white or brown rice. Add proteins marinated flank steak, grilled chicken, or cajican spiced chicken.
Protein Bowl Station
Salad Bar
Build Your Salad
Craft your salad with a wide selection of fresh elements including greens like romaine and iceberg lettuce, toppings like cucumbers, olives, onions, and more. Choose to toss or chop.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Classic caesar salad with marinated grilled chicken.
Southwestern Chicken Salad
Cajun spiced chicken, romaine lettuce, corn, tomato, black olives, crunchy tortilla strips served with ranch dressing.
Gorgonberry Salad
Grilled chicken, mixed baby greens, gorgonzola cheese, walnuts, dried cranberries served with raspberry vinaigrette.
Chef's Salad
Romaine lettuce, turkey, ham, swiss cheese, american cheese, tomato, cucumbers, onions, with sliced hardboiled eggs.
Small Acai Bowl
Acai fruit, coconut, granola, banana, strawberries, blueberries, and drizzle of honey.
Large Acai Bowl
Acai fruit, coconut, granola, banana, strawberries, blueberries, and drizzle of honey.
Acai Bowl
Hot Soups
Chicken Noodle Soup
Chicken noodle soup is good for the soul.
Vegetable Soup
Freshly prepared vegetable soup in two size options: large (16oz) or small (12oz).
Classic Oatmeal
Add brown sugar, cinnamon, fresh strawberries, granola, maple syrup, raisins, dried cranberries, and or walnuts.
Hot Oatmeal
Spreads, Salads & More
Plain Cream Cheese
Plain cream cheese.
Flavored Cream Cheese
Savor the rich and creamy texture of our unique selections such as scallion, strawberry, chocolate chip, jalapeno cheddar, green olive, and maple walnut.
Chicken Salad
Enjoy a hearty chicken salad.
Tuna Salad
Butter
Enjoy a simple but pleasing butter spread.
Whitefish Salad
Enjoy our whitefish salad.
Macaroni Salad
Savor our flavorful macaroni salad, perfectly combined to offer a satisfying breakfast.
Egg Salad
Enjoy the comfort of classic, creamy egg salad. This dish combines carefully boiled and chopped eggs, mixed meticulously with a smooth, palatable dressing. Garnished with ripe, juicy tomato strips, it's a true delight. Completing the dish is a dusting of sweet, aromatic paprika.
Cucumber Salad
A refreshing cucumber salad.
Vegetable Tuna Salad
A wholesome vegetable tuna salad.
Grilled Chicken
Potato Salad
Homemade potato salad.
Cole Slaw
Enjoy a side dish of our cole slaw prepared with crisp cabbage and carrots, finely chopped in a mayonnaise-based sauce.
Lox Cream Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Enjoy a flavorful salad composed of tender chunks of chicken infused with a fiery buffalo sauce, meticulously tossed with freshly chopped veggies. The taste is balanced perfectly by a creamy dressing atop this breakfast delight. Served in your chosen size.
BLT Chicken Salad
Chicken salad featuring bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Breaded Chicken Cutlet
1 lb.
Nova
Offered in 3 sizes.
Lox
Lox served by the pound, offered in 3 sizes.
Fried Eggplant
1 lb.
Baked Salmon Salad
Honey Mustard Chicken Salad
Deep River Snacks
Gluten-free kettle potato chips.
Hal's New York
Gluten-free kettle potato chips.
Snickers
Hershey's chocolate
Hershey's Cookies & Cream
Snacks
Desserts
Muffins
Blueberry crumb, corn, chocolate chip, chocolate chocolate chip.
Fruit Cup
Includes grapes, cantaloupe, and melon.
Black & White Cookie
Cheese Danish
Brownie
Vanilla Yogurt & Granola Parfait
Includes blueberries.
Croissant
Apple Turnover
Blueberry Turnover
Rice Pudding
Strawberry Yogurt & Granola Parfait
Homemade. Includes blueberries.
Crumb Cake
A deliciously moist, delicately sweet cake offering a lush velvety interior, topped with a layer of crunchy crumbs. Available in plain, infused with zesty apple, or tangy cherry flavours.
Pound Cake
A delightful pound cake available in different flavors: chocolate, marble, lemon, plain, red velvet, lemon poppy, and blueberry.
Bottled Drinks
A variety of bottled drinks, including nestle flavored waters, sparkling ice, soft drinks, snapple, arizona iced teas, tropicana juices in various sizes, and diet options.
Iced Tea
Iced Coffee
Enjoy a refreshing iced coffee available in various flavors including vanilla, decaf, black, hazelnut, or coffee crumb. Choose your preferred size - small or large.
Coffee
Enjoy a warm beverage of your choice with flavor options including vanilla, coffee crumb, hazelnut, or classic black. Choose from large, medium, or small sizes. Decaf available too..
Lemonade
Homemade! Delicious lemonade.
Tropicana Orange, 48oz
Original RedBull
A revitalizing energy drink, available in its original 12 oz. size or as an 8.4oz option in original.
Sugar Free RedBull
A revitalizing energy drink, available in its original 12 oz. size or as an 8.4oz option in sugar-free versions.
Hot Tea
Enjoy a hot tea of your preferred size, with an array of tea bag options available including regular decaf, peppermint, green tea, chamomile, earl grey, regular lipton, decaf green tea, lemon ginger, and mandarin orange spice.
Poland Spring Water
Poland spring water, available in sports bottle, regular, or 1 liter sizes.
16 oz. Monster Energy
16.9 oz. Prime Hydration Drink
12oz Fresh Home Made Orange
16 oz. Calypso Southern Peach Lemonade
15 oz. Starbucks Double Shots Energy
9.5 oz. Starbucks Frappuccino
10 oz. Martinellis Apple Juice
Hal's Flavored Seltzer
Enjoy the refreshing sparkle of seltzer, infused with a variety of natural fruit flavors. Options range from tangy lemon to exotic mango, subtle black cherry to vibrant watermelon. A no-flavor option is also available.
Essentia Water
Enjoy a refreshing essentia water, available in different sizes: 1 liter, 20 oz. or opt for our sports bottle. Great for hydration any time of the day.
Fresh Squeezed Orange juice
we juice orange every morning.